Let's set the record straight: Robert Chatigny's nomination to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, one of the most prestigious federal judgeships in the nation, did not fail because of excessive partisanship. It failed because Chatigny was temperamentally unsuited for the position. Chatigny is not a victim. President Barack Obama should seize the opportunity created by Chatigny's failure to appoint a trial lawyer to the court. Such a move is long overdue.
Chatigny was appointed to serve as a United States District Court Judge by Bill Clinton long ago. At the time...
January 6, 2011
The California Supreme Court doesn't think there is any real difference between a crumpled up cigarette package, the clothing on your back or your cell phone: All three are intimately associated with you. Hence, should you be arrested, police officers can search all three items under an exception to the Fourth Amendment's warrant requirement known as "search incident to arrest." A majority of the elected high court in California so ruled this week in People v. Diaz. The ruling reminds me once again that we get the government we deserved.
California from time to time tries to opt out of...
January 5, 2011
Reading Chief Justice John G. Roberts call for an end to partisanship in the selection of federal judges felt alot like watching professional football players sing the national anthem before a game: For a brief moment, it's all peace and unity. Once the whisle blows, expect the hitting to be hard, fast and furious. The chief's singing of judicial Kumbaya before the New Year began was hardly persuasive. But for the machinations of the right, he wouldn't be sitting where he is today.
"Each political party has found it easy to turn on a dime from decrying to defending the blocking of...
January 3, 2011
The new year has scarcely begun, but already battle lines are drawn in what will be one of the most significant struggles of 2011: Welcome to the border wars. The New York Times reports that a handful of states have proposed legisation to address immigration issues the federal government cannot handle. "The federal government's failure to enforce our border has functionally turned every state into a border state," Oklahoma lawmaker Randy Terrill told the Times. "The states are stepping in and filling the void left by the federal government.
Arizona acted last year, giving state lawmen...
January 2, 2011
December 31, 2010
"Why the defense of those accused of crimes?" It is a natural enough question. I stop to ponder it today after being accused of a species of...
December 30, 2010
There is a great line dividing Americans: On the one side, and tipping the scales of justice, are those who have never been accused of a crime; on...
December 29, 2010
At year's end news organizations like to mark time by doing such things as selecting, and commenting upon, the year's top stories. Some, like Time...
December 27, 2010
Someone tell me: Just how did it happen that I need to defend my right to die? Death is part of life, the tail end of a bargain none of us struck....
December 27, 2010
I read this year's Best Crime Reporting with a guilty sort of pleasure. It was a gift, so reading it over the holidays was appropriate enough. But...
December 26, 2010
Last year's end-of-the-year essay provoked a chain of events that turned into something strangely liberating. I wrote of the great emotional travail...