What Next In Wisconsin, A Suit Against God?

Is Madeline Neumann dead today because her parents did not take her to a doctor? Or is she dead because God did not answer her parents' prayers to heal her? The answer is both. But why are only the parents facing prison?

The problem of evil is one theologians just can't lick. Justifying the ways of God to man is hard work. In our talk-show world, we ask: Why do bad things happen to good people?

Ms. Neumann was 11-years-old when she died. She grew progressively more ill as her parents and neighbors stood around her, asking God to heal her. She lost the ability to walk, then she could not eat, then she could not talk or speak. When she stopped breathing, someone finally called 911. It was too late. Doctors say the child died of juvenile diabetes, and that is she had only been given insulin, she'd be alive now.

The State of Wisconsin has charged both parents with reckless homicide. Both have been convicted at separate trials. They each face 25 years in prison.

Mr. Neumann told jurors he did not take his daughter to the hospital because God has promised to heal, and taking her to doctors would be putting man before God. The Wisconsin state's attorney prosecuting the case calls Mr. Neumann "overwhelmed by pride." Neither Neumann nor the prosecutor inspire much faith in humanity.

Mr. Neumann, frankly, is a throwback to William Jennings Bryan and the days of the Scopes monkey trial. Sure, the man has a narrow, cramped, literalistic and foolish sort of commitment to each jot and tittle of the Bible. And he's darn tootin' if he'll let anyone stand between himself and the written word of God.

But the prosecutor looks far worse. What public purpose is served by trying to lock up mom and dad for what amounts to misplaced faith? Sure, the couple should have sought medical treatment for their daughter. They did expose her to risk of death. And the poor child died. But for all that, what the couple did hardly looks like a crime, unless gullibility and stupidity are crimes, in which case we are all from time to time guilty.

We burned witches at various points in prison. Now we lock up people whose only crime it is to believe in the efficacy of prayer. I am not sure how to strike a decent middle ground, but I nonetheless feel free to cry foul when the extremes are so vividly put on display. The case(s) of State v. Neumann are cruel, unusual and worthy solely of scorn. Shame on Wisconsin. What next, a writ against God for not answering the Neumann's prayers?

Comments: (3)

  • Basisally the State is saying your God is no good,...
    Basisally the State is saying your God is no good, he is not all powerfull and your prayers will never be answered. You need to turn to the State for they are the true almighty and can do all, just watch we will pass a law.
    Posted on September 1, 2009 at 1:42 am by wisconsinite
  • Richard Dawkins, in his book "The God Delusion" de...
    Richard Dawkins, in his book "The God Delusion" describes a double blind study regarding the clinical effectiveness of prayer which appeared in the April, 2006 edition of the "American Heart Journal." The study, funded by The Templeton Foundation, arrived at the troubling conclusion that there were no clinical differences in complications or recovery among post surgical heart patients where the patients of one group were the subject of organized prayers and the other group was not. There was a third group of similar patients who were also prayed for but this group was informed they were being prayed for while the other group was not so informed. This group had far more complications than the other two groups.
    Posted on September 2, 2009 at 12:09 pm by verlasky
  • God bless you Mr Pattis, for you wise piece.
    If he...
    God bless you Mr Pattis, for you wise piece.
    If he doesn't formally reply, then well wishes are in order from those who appreciate your wisdom, much in display.
    Some say God is an invention of man.
    Some God's are not an others God.
    Man is sometimes too ill equipped to understand all the things in the world, and all forces whatever they be.
    God is now the target of blame.
    Some blamed Katrina on God, others blamed World War II.
    Some times authority, & power marches to its own drummer, often out of step on the fragile human conditon, blind to its weakness, its nature of being only so human, which is to say, not exactly perfect in all things.
    Perhaps, you should be a Governor one day, one could only hope,to commute silly sentences that do not serve any sense of justice.
    Posted on October 17, 2009 at 4:53 pm by Anonymous

Add a Comment

Display with comment:
Won't show with comment:
Number of states in the U.S.
*Comment must be approved and then will show on page.
© Norm Pattis is represented by Elite Lawyer Management, managing agents for Exceptional American Lawyers
Media & Speaker booking [hidden email]